In this article:

One of our members sat down recently and pictured a training session before it happened. The woods, the undergrowth, smells everywhere, a dog who had never worked in that environment before. She could see him losing his head, going into full fun mode, ignoring every word. She could see everything going wrong. So she was seriously considering not going at all.

If you have ever done that same mental rehearsal, this post is for you. It covers why waiting for your dog to behave before getting help keeps you stuck, what difficult behaviour is often really telling you, and why the hardest dogs so often become the best ones.

Everything in this post comes from my conversation with Claire Denyer on episode [EP NUMBER 211] of Found It, Fetched It.

Listen Here:

Your Trainer Wants to See Your Dog at His Worst

Claire gets the same email regularly. A client asks to push their session back a couple of weeks because the dog is not doing very well at the moment and they do not want to come along and be embarrassed. Her answer is always the same: that is why we are here.

Think about it from the trainer’s side. If your dog turns up and does not put a foot wrong, the session might look like brilliant progress. But if the tricky behaviour only happens at home or out on your walks, your trainer never sees it. And a trainer cannot help you fix something they have never witnessed. What they see is a very different dog to the one you live with.

Claire tells her handlers it is actually better if the dog brings its cheekiest behaviour to the session. That is when she can hand over the right toolkit, the right methods and the right approach, and send you home equipped. Maybe your dog is good as gold at home afterwards and you barely need any of it. That is a far better outcome than a dog who performs beautifully in class and falls apart everywhere else.

The takeaway is simple. Stop treating your session like a performance your dog has to pass. It is a diagnosis, and the symptoms need to show up for it to work.

The Shame Spiral That Keeps You Training Alone

When your dog is hard work, there is a lot of feeling attached to it. You stop taking him where people can see him. You train alone so nobody witnesses the chaos. Some handlers will not even take the dog around family, because they do not want the people closest to them to see what he has become. The shame quietly builds a wall around you and the dog, and behind that wall nothing improves.

When our member shared her worry with the community, the responses were not judgement. They were recognition. One member wrote that she was laughing because it all sounded so familiar. Another told her that honestly, her dog sounded fab and just needed channeling. Person after person saying we go through the same.

Claire’s own comment cut to it: it does not sound as bad as you think it is. When you are the one holding the lead in the moment, everything feels bigger than it looks from the outside. We hang on to the one thing that went wrong and forget everything that went right.

Here is the shift. The fear of judgement is not really about what other people think. It is about what we think other people think. Once that lands, the whole journey gets lighter.

Difficult Now Often Means Brilliant Later

Here is the part nobody tells you when you are stood in a field being ignored: the most difficult dogs can go on to become the hardest working, most competitive, dog of a lifetime dogs.

Claire sees it constantly. The dogs that feel like a challenge early on are often the independent ones, the problem solvers, the ones with genuine drive who want to go and hunt the thing. That drive is exhausting at eighteen months. It is exactly what you want in a dog working in the field or in competition later. And working through those challenges together is what builds the deep bond. You come out the other side with a relationship the easy dogs never demanded of you.

Maturity plays its part too. Some dogs, especially some boy dogs, take two to three years to go from goofy puppy thing to a dog that wants to learn a craft. I see it in my own two. Rex is easy and super fun, and he lulled me into forgetting what it took to get there. Then Arthur came charging in and I caught myself asking why he could not be more like Rex. But Rex had time to become Rex.

So when you are comparing your young dog to someone’s steady five year old, remember you are comparing chapters, not dogs. Give yours the time to become himself.

Your Dog Is Not Being Naughty, He Is Telling You Something

A lot of what gets labelled difficult is not defiance at all. It is communication we have not learned to read yet.

Take scent marking. Yes, male dogs scent mark. But it can also be a displacement behaviour, a sign the dog is worried or avoiding something. Claire regularly sees dogs that have been reprimanded by previous trainers for behaviours that were actually the dog trying to say something. Find the real reason, fix that, and the behaviour disappears. The same goes for the great national scandal of dogs humping cushions. It is rarely what people think it is. Claire’s dog Rose humps her bed after her afternoon meal, every day, and only then. Seven years old and it has been her happy little ritual since she was one.

Claire shared a recent case that shows how deep this goes. A young golden retriever came to her with a recall problem, referred by a local vet. Face to face, the dog did everything asked of it. The moment its back was turned to the owner, nothing. Claire suspected a hearing problem and sent them for a vet check. Hearing fine. Which means the dog has most likely learned every command with a visual cue attached, and genuinely does not understand the words alone. All those times we lift a hand without noticing while saying sit, the dog is reading our body, not our voice.

Before you label your dog difficult, ask what he might be telling you instead. That one question changes everything you do next.

The Fast Track Most Handlers Never Use

There is a layer of learning that has nothing to do with holding your own lead: watching other dogs work.

Group classes are the obvious place. Once your foundations are solid enough for your dog to cope in a group, you get two educations for the price of one. Your dog learns to be steady around other dogs and people, and you learn from watching every other dog in the class. Claire even builds it in deliberately. If a dog is still building duration on its self control, she will suggest popping him in the car between retrieves so the handler can come back and watch the other dogs calmly, rather than standing there struggling for five minutes while learning nothing.

And if your dog cannot take part at all, perhaps she is coming into season or carrying an injury, come anyway. Watch, learn, take it home. Claire encourages her clients to do exactly that rather than miss the class.

Volunteering at a working charity test takes this even further. Watching sixty dogs run in front of you gives you pattern recognition no book can. You start spotting the warning moment: the nose that hits the air, the head that follows a scent, the whole dog switching focus a full second before he takes off. Handlers who have watched hundreds of dogs see it coming. Handlers who have only ever watched their own dog say he just disappeared.

Questions people ask about training a badly behaved dog

Should I wait until my dog behaves better before booking a trainer?

No, and it is the most expensive mistake you can make with time. Every repetition of an unwanted behaviour moves it closer to habit, and habits are far harder to undo than fresh problems. Your trainer needs to see the behaviour to help you fix it. Go now, with the dog you actually have.

What if my dog embarrasses me in front of the trainer or the class?

Your trainer has seen it all, and a good one will meet you with kindness, compassion and a plan rather than judgement. Claire actively wants dogs to bring their cheekiest behaviour to sessions because that is what she can work with. The embarrassment feels enormous from your end of the lead, but it usually looks far smaller from the outside.

My spaniel bolts into the undergrowth the second we are somewhere new. Why?

His nose is picking up things you cannot begin to detect, so what looks random to you is completely logical to him. There is almost always a warning moment first, a nose in the air, a head tracking a scent, the dog’s whole focus shifting away from you. Learning to spot that moment is the skill, and watching other dogs work is one of the fastest ways to build it.

Is my dog being dominant when he scent marks or humps things?

Almost certainly not. These are very often displacement behaviours, signs of worry, avoidance or overexcitement rather than a bid for power. Punishing them without understanding the cause tends to make things worse. Find the reason behind the behaviour and the behaviour usually resolves itself.

How long before my difficult young dog settles down?

Every dog is different, and some, particularly some males, take two to three years to mature into a dog that wants to learn a craft. That is not a training failure, it is a timeline. The drive making him hard work now is the same drive that could make him exceptional later.

Go Anyway

If you are sat there running the film of everything that could go wrong at your next session, class or test, I understand. I have run that film myself. Every handler with a high drive dog has.

But here is what happened to the member whose worry started this whole conversation. The community gave her confidence. The trainers gave her the clear, simple truth: go along anyway, this is how the dog learns. So she went.

She had a blast. And her dog, the one she was certain would lose his head in the woods? He was really, really well behaved. Really brilliant, in fact.

The dog you are worried about showing a trainer is the dog a trainer most wants to meet. Book the session.

Listen to the full episode:
Episode [EP NUMBER 211]: Think Your Dog Is Too Badly Behaved for a Trainer? That Is Exactly When to Go

Ready to stop guessing and start leading?
Join the LWDG membership and get the framework, the community, and the expert support to do this for real.

Not sure where to start?
Take the free LWDG Level Finder and find out exactly where you and your dog are right now.